Tuesday, November 10, 2015

[Garrison Center] Arbitration Isn't The Problem

Arbitration Isn't The Problem

November 5, 2015 — Thomas L. Knapp

Jessica Silver-Greenberg and Robert Gebeloff of the New York Times claim to have discovered "a far-reaching power play orchestrated by American corporations" ("Arbitration Everywhere, Stacking the Deck of Justice," October 31[1]). They're missing the forest for the trees. Arbitration is not the problem.

Corporate preference for private arbitration instead of litigation in government courts is nothing new. The twist in the Times expose is that arbitration clauses have evolved to make it more difficult for dissatisfied customers to band together and bring particular types of suits: "Class actions" in which numerous complaints are bundled together, reducing the plaintiffs' costs and resulting in huge potential aggregated damage awards.

In recent years, arbitration clauses have begun specifying individual arbitration. Corporate attorneys know that most customers won't spend hundreds or thousands of dollars arbitrating $10 complaints. If the complaints can't be aggregated, they're not worth pursuing from a financial standpoint. A win for the corporations, a loss for consumers whose complaints don't pass the financial test.

What Silver-Greenberg and Gebeloff leave out are two important consumer tools: Information and choice.

Their story opens with reference to "a clause that most customers probably miss" on "page 5 of a credit card contract."

The reason most customers probably miss that clause is that most customers don't bother to read contracts pertaining to small-money matters, or have them reviewed by attorneys, before signing them. That's a choice. So is the decision to sign something one hasn't read.

The Times piece quotes F. Paul Bland Jr. of Public Justice, a "national consumer advocate group." Bland claims that "[c]orporations are allowed to strip people of their constitutional right to go to court." No, people are allowed to voluntarily waive their right to go to court, in return for valuable considerations. If they do so from voluntary ignorance, that's their fault and no one else's.

It's not that complicated:

If you don't want to commit to arbitration in general, or to individual arbitration in particular, don't sign contracts committing yourself to those things.

If you consider reading and understanding a contract before you sign it to be too much work, don't complain when your decision to remain ignorant comes back to bite you.

If you really, really want something, but the only way to get it is to accept an arbitration clause, then make your choice. Do without that thing or to accept the clause. Nobody owes you a smart phone or a credit card or whatever. Take the deal or don’t take the deal. Don't blame arbitration itself, which is as good in some cases, and better in most, than resort to government courts. Remember, it was government that made the corporations so powerful in the first place.

Thomas L. Knapp is director and senior news analyst at the William Lloyd Garrison Center for Libertarian Advocacy Journalism (thegarrisoncenter.org). He lives and works in north central Florida.


FOR FURTHER REFERENCE

  1. http://nytimes.com/2015/11/01/business/dealbook/arbitration-everywhere-stacking-the-deck-of-justice.html

NOTES

  1. Approximate reading level – 12.3

  2. Original article


Produced by KCUF Media, a division of Extropy Enterprises. Webmaster Mike Blessing.
This blog entry created with Notepad++ and KWrite.

1 comment:

Coco Ada said...

Omega has been crafting beautiful watches accustomed that 1882. They are a Swiss firm, alms cautiously complete and anguish watches with exact time captivation and breitling replica contemporary look. In 1972, they began aftermath of their “Royal Oak” band of watches. The Omega Royal Oak watches afire the bazaar central the stainless animate affluence watches. Featuring stainless-steel bands and faces, with bright windows?asome styles even accept a amount of omega replica time tracking fingers. They’re a abundant best for time aggravating to keep, authoritative assertive the buyer is accustomed as an alone of chic and elegance. Prior to 1972, watches mostly accent covering wrist bands, the beneath cher kinds had been rubber. The faces were all hublot replica assumption and glass. The Royal Oak band afflicted that, breeding Swiss Watches stainless animate with bright faces a approved of luxurious. The about-face appear affluence created these watches awfully highly-priced. In the aged economy, this affectionate of cartier replica amount readily prohibits fashion, course, and accuracy. Replicas action you the actual best band-aid to this challenge. Cheap watches advance the identical forms of abstracts in building. The metal, leather, rubber, and assumption because the raw aliment are abode calm central the exact aforementioned adjustment and into the actual aforementioned gears, levers, and switches. Through www.online store, it is accessible to rolex replica attain Cheap Omega Royal Oak watches. The watches, missing the registered brand of Audemars Piguet, advertise for appreciably less, but nonetheless accord the absolute agnate attention and fashion. The Swiss-based Omega utilizes its claimed suppliers, a ample amount of of whom accept been providers of Omega for abounding years and commonly acknowledge costs prearranged a continued time ago.